Shelby Miller deal revisited

I wonder whats going to happen in AZ if they dont turn things around. Really hoping for a firesale so we can finally get Greinke!
 
Cards get Heyward and walden
Braves get Miller and Jenkins

I think that deal was pretty even especially with Heyward bolting after the season and walden with severe injury issues

Dbacks get Miller and spiere(?)
Braves get Swanson Blair and Inciarte

No doubt win for the braves right now. Season is the future face of the organization. Blair has looked really solid for us in the minors and few mlb starts. Inciarte will be real good once off injury.

I was heavily against trading Inciarte in the offseason partly because I didn't fully trust mallex yet. But based on what I've seen mallex can hang with the big club, if we get a stupid offer and obvious win I could trade Inciarte
 
bravesfanforlife88 said:
Cards get Heyward and walden
Braves get Miller and Jenkins

I think that deal was pretty even especially with Heyward bolting after the season and walden with severe injury issues

Dbacks get Miller and spiere(?)
Braves get Swanson Blair and Inciarte

No doubt win for the braves right now. Season is the future face of the organization. Blair has looked really solid for us in the minors and few mlb starts. Inciarte will be real good once off injury.

I was heavily against trading Inciarte in the offseason partly because I didn't fully trust mallex yet. But based on what I've seen mallex can hang with the big club, if we get a stupid offer and obvious win I could trade Inciarte
Click to expand...

I want to see Ender AND Mallex out there. It would be a huge mistake to trade Ender, I think. Probably my favorite player on the Braves right now.
 
Dalyn said:
I want to see Ender AND Mallex out there. It would be a huge mistake to trade Ender, I think. Probably my favorite player on the Braves right now.
Click to expand...

I wanna see more of him, but I love what he brings to the table overall. I'm also hesitant to trade him due to the lack of OFers we have in the system.
 
Hey I agree I love Inciarte. I'm just saying that if we are blown away on a deal then you have to consider it. But we have him under control for a long time so let's see what both of them can do in the outfield
 
yeezus said:
they weren't as mad as I thought they'd be.
maybe this place has me conditioned.
Click to expand...

Honestly, they don't seem to be extremely bright. Several at least partially justified by saying they were in position to 'go for it'. First, that team was never really in position to truly go for it. Second, that trade made them obviously worse long-term but also likely worse as soon as midseason this year.
 
Definitely a win for the Braves because of Swanson. I don't think long term Blair or Inciarte are pieces that are going to truly come back to haunt the Dbacks. Swanson absolutely looks like that piece though
 
emk418 said:
Definitely a win for the Braves because of Swanson. I don't think long term Blair or Inciarte are pieces that are going to truly come back to haunt the Dbacks. Swanson absolutely looks like that piece though
Click to expand...

But Inciarte is already a very good major league player, and Blair has the chance to be that as well. Swanson may end up being the best piece, and maybe even the only guy with a chance to be a multi-year All-Star, but all 3 absolutely have the chance to be really valuable pieces. Giving that up for one good pitcher (who so far has been downright terrible) is not good.

Even if it was only Inciarte and Blair, that probably ends up being an obvious win for the Braves.
 
smootness said:
Honestly, they don't seem to be extremely bright. Several at least partially justified by saying they were in position to 'go for it'. First, that team was never really in position to truly go for it. Second, that trade made them obviously worse long-term but also likely worse as soon as midseason this year.
Click to expand...

and they were saying Swanson wouldn't be relevant il 2017.
Currently they are starting Nick Ahmed there. I think Swanson would be better instantly.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top