Wren's Biggest FAIL of 2014 season

50PoundHead said:


Small sample size and all, but Schafer has an .818 OPS since going to Minnesota, where he's playing almost every day. He may not be made for the bench, where you have to find ways to keep sharp (and Doumit is also an example of how a decent player can look futile with sporadic action), but he's a guy who has to play more than he did. He's still second on the team in SBs even though he's not here and he'll probably have over 30 by the end of the season. Don't get me wrong, I don't think Schafer should have necessarily played more in Atlanta, but I don't see how Cunningham would have made any difference.
Click to expand...

.163 .256 .213 .468

That's what he did in Atlanta this year. No way Cunningham wouldn't have been a huge improvement. Might've even performed well enough to get BJ some time off. As bad as BJ sucked, he didn't suck as much as his replacement on the active roster. That hurt.
 
I think Schafer is a guy who has to play with some regularity to perform well. He did it in Atlanta before getting injured in 2013 and he's doing it now in Minnesota. He's no world-beater, but he's a better player than what he showed this year for the Braves.

Fredi found ways to incorporate both Pena and Schafer in the line-up effectively in 2013, but he did an about-face this year and has pretty much went with a set line-up with little slotting of reserves until the past couple of weeks. If I have any beef with Gonzalez this year, it is that departure from a pattern that worked well for the team last year.
 
50PoundHead said:
I think Schafer is a guy who has to play with some regularity to perform well. He did it in Atlanta before getting injured in 2013 and he's doing it now in Minnesota. He's no world-beater, but he's a better player than what he showed this year for the Braves.

Fredi found ways to incorporate both Pena and Schafer in the line-up effectively in 2013, but he did an about-face this year and has pretty much went with a set line-up with little slotting of reserves until the past couple of weeks. If I have any beef with Gonzalez this year, it is that departure from a pattern that worked well for the team last year.
Click to expand...

Well put. And, IMO, it's not even regularity that guys like Schafer/Doumit need(ed) but semi-regularity.

A lot of posters want to dump on Schafer, particularly, but his skillset is really perfect for a PH/defensive replacement/pinch runner/4th OF and it doesn't surprise me to see him succeeding in Minnesota.

Somebody earlier in the thread mentioned Bobby's plus ability at utilizing his bench and making all of his players feel useful -- and it always seemed like production came around to match the (sometimes confounding) amount of playing time he gave his bench bats.

Between poor bench management and the desecration of the bullpen, it's hard to find anything much to like about Fredi nowadays aside from the whole 'he keeps an even keel' proposition.
 
Hawk said:
Well put. And, IMO, it's not even regularity that guys like Schafer/Doumit need(ed) but semi-regularity.

A lot of posters want to dump on Schafer, particularly, but his skillset is really perfect for a PH/defensive replacement/pinch runner/4th OF and it doesn't surprise me to see him succeeding in Minnesota.
Click to expand...

Schafer is a decent 5th outfielder used mainly for running and defense and bunting. But there is no room for such a player on a bad bench.
 
Hawk said:
Somebody earlier in the thread mentioned Bobby's plus ability at utilizing his bench and making all of his players feel useful -- and it always seemed like production came around to match the (sometimes confounding) amount of playing time he gave his bench bats.

Between poor bench management and the desecration of the bullpen, it's hard to find anything much to like about Fredi nowadays aside from the whole 'he keeps an even keel' proposition.
Click to expand...

I agree with this, though I will say that Fredi's whole "even keel" thing seems more and more like a deer caught in the headlights.

Many of us have complained about not giving time off to Freeman and CJ. He did the same thing to both last year, that's why CJ couldn't win the batting title. He was exhausted in September. That's also why I think Fredi has a below .500 record in September. He exhausts his starters during the season and has a freezing cold bench he has to fall back on when they can't even walk at the end of the year.
 
GovClintonTyree said:
By the way, the bench is pretty good, now. Lots of good pieces and versatility. I'd sit Heyward against tough lefties and BJ against all righties, split about 30% of 3B at bats to other than CJ, Laird every fifth day, straight platoon 2B, and rest Simmons a little more.

I'd also like to bring up The Deuce and drop BJ, but that ain't happening. Have to wait another week.
Click to expand...

The bench is terrible, what are you talking about?
 
Dalyn said:
Schafer is a decent 5th outfielder used mainly for running and defense and bunting. But there is no room for such a player on a bad bench.
Click to expand...

Truth -- and I should add that my defense of Schafer does not mean that I believe the Braves should've retained him. Given the circumstances, it was time for him to go (both to 'improve' the bench and to allow him a shot at continuing his career in ... greener pastures.)

That being said, I like to see late season benches for teams in contention be comprised primarily of veterans/character types (like Jason Giambi, Michael Young) that wear the grizzled cachet well. Of course, they need to still be able to perform, too. Atlanta doesn't have anybody like that now, and I don't think it's a coincidence that some of the Braves best benches in recent years had guys like Eric Hinske/David Ross/Matt Diaz/Reed Johnson commanding them.
 
GovClintonTyree said:
I am less inclined to nitpick every single in-game decision that Fredi makes and more inclined to question trends.

And he just hasn't used his bench enough this year. Doumit can hit, but nobody can stay sharp with 10 at bats a month.
Click to expand...

For all the Jordan Schafer haters this also holds true. He had 93 plate appearances in 63 games as a brave. As a Twin he has had 66 PA in 18 games. Since going to Minnesota he has hit .302 with a .403 OB percentage and stolen 8 bases. The only month he had any ab to speak of while here was June, which of course was his best month as a brave in 2014. Other than that he had no more than 17 at bats in any month.

A great manager puts players in a position to succeed, bad managers do not........
 
depley said:
For all the Jordan Schafer haters this also holds true. He had 93 plate appearances in 63 games as a brave. As a Twin he has had 66 PA in 18 games. Since going to Minnesota he has hit .302 with a .403 OB percentage and stolen 8 bases. The only month he had any ab to speak of while here was June, which of course was his best month as a brave in 2014. Other than that he had no more than 17 at bats in any month.
A great manager puts players in a position to succeed, bad managers do not........
Click to expand...
Don't blame Schafer's failure to succeed in Atl on the manager. He wasn't going to play in front of BJ at $75 million and he was never gonna play the corners so the ab's he needs weren't there.
 
VirginiaBrave said:
Don't blame Schafer's failure to succeed in Atl on the manager. He wasn't going to play in front of BJ at $75 million and he was never gonna play the corners so the ab's he needs weren't there.
Click to expand...

Who makes out the lineup? The manager. You keep running out a player based on his salary you end up with what you get, last year BJ and Uggla, this year BJ.
 
depley said:
Who makes out the lineup? The manager. You keep running out a player based on his salary you end up with what you get, last year BJ and Uggla, this year BJ.
Click to expand...

You seriously believe Fredi would bench a $75 million dollar player? The FO wouldn't allow it. No matter how bad he has been. Of the two Frank deserves to go first, he shops for the groceries after all.
 
depley said:
For all the Jordan Schafer haters this also holds true. He had 93 plate appearances in 63 games as a brave. As a Twin he has had 66 PA in 18 games. Since going to Minnesota he has hit .302 with a .403 OB percentage and stolen 8 bases. The only month he had any ab to speak of while here was June, which of course was his best month as a brave in 2014. Other than that he had no more than 17 at bats in any month.
A great manager puts players in a position to succeed, bad managers do not........
Click to expand...

Schafer isn't a good baseball player. Not bad against RHP, total ass against LHP. Only way we can find any value for him is to super strict platoon him with BJ.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top