Also it does make me wonder how that match against Germany in 2002 would have turned out if we could have had a prime Tim Howard in goal although I know Brad friedel had a pretty good run
Friedel was better than Howard.
That will answer part of it haha.
Personally I go
Friedel
Howard
Keller
On ability and career including club but on what they did for the NT
Howard
Keller
Friedel
Friedel's stint with the NT was short and dominant. And his club record was the best.
Then you can debate Hahnemann, Guzan, and Meola.
I think people forget that Friedel saved 2 penalties during regulation. Joining only 2 other keepers to ever do that in the World Cup. Jan Tomaszewski, Brad Friedel and former Arsenal and
@The Tariff King favorite Woj Szczęsny. It's weird he's there with 2 Polish keepers.
Honestly it's crazy to me the change. In 2010 our world cup starting outfield was
LB - Carlos Bocanegra (out of position) Rennes
CB - Demerit - no squad, wasn't retained by watford and didn't sign with anyone til november that year for Vancouver FC
CB - Onyewu - AC Milan - Big Club but he wasn't playing. He only played 1 game I think for Milan.
RB - Cherundolo - Hannover
CM - Bradley - Monchen Gladbach (they weren't that good back then)
CM - Clark - Frankfurt (not a starter)
LM - Dempsey - Fulham
RM - Donovan - LA
ST - Altidore - Villareal/Hull (didn't do great for hull with 1 league goal)
ST - Buddle - LA Galaxy
So that squad is guys on bigger teams and bigger leagues not playing much, MLSers, out of position Boca and Bradley, Dempsey, Altidore and Cherundolo
Compare that to potentially
LB - Robinson - Fulham - soon to Manchester United or Aston Villa, consided potentially one of the 3 or 4 best LBs in the premier league.
CB - Chris Richards - Crystal Palace Starter
CB - Mark McKenzie Toulouse
RB - Dest - PSV
CM - Adams - BOurnmouth
CM - Johnny - Atletico (not starting lately but had a really long run and has
CM - McKennie - Juventus
RW - Weah - Marseille
ST - Balogun - Monaco
LW - Pulisic - AC Milan
Who's not included are starters/regulars for European teams like
Brendan Aaronson(Leeds)
Ricardo Pepi (PSV tied to a fulham move)
Malik Tillman (Leverkusen)
Scally (Monchengladbach)
Tessman (lyon)
Lund (Koln)
Fossey (Standard Liege)
Campbell (WBA)
Busio (Venezia
Wright (Coventry)
Downs (Southampton/Hamburg)
And all that doesn't include maybe 2 of the most talented players in our pool who have club issues in Gio Reyna and Yunus Musah. If you told me we had a 23 year old who used to regularly play for Valencia and AC Milan but is having a rough patch, I would think he'd still be in the starting mix. But Musah probably doesn't make the squad. I personally bring him over a few guys who've been getting calls lately like Roldan because Roldan sucks for the NT.
I honestly see 2 problems with the team and they're huge, CB and GK. All our Keepers are MLS guys. Not that I have a huge issue with MLS, but we used to have guys who took their talents to England and Germany. Our only GK prospect currently actively playing in Europe who has been in camp in the last year is Jonathan Klinsmann who's playing in Serie B. I honestly debate if a pure prospect like DIego Kochen isn't better than some of the guys we've been using. Gaga Slonina has struggled to get a hold in Europe, we're desolate at the position. I think Freese has played well overall but it's clearly the weakest keeper we've had going into a World Cup in my life time. Even Turner last time was at least an elite shot stopper (he doesn't have it anymore)