6/19/15: GDT - NY Mets @ Atlanta Braves

zitothebrave said:
I admitted several times I had no real opinion on Hanson because from watching him live I couldn't see anything.

I rarely say anything about a pitcher if I have nothing to say. Minor for example almost certainly has something wrong with his mechanics because he's had shoulder issues. There's a handful of guys who I've said have great mechanics and most aren't playing now. And when you're dealing with something like mechanics where a hundreth of a second can be the difference between good and bad, sometimes you have to go to the super slow motion or ideally, frame by frame because frame by frame lets you really see everything. Only pitchers I've said seem to have good mechanics out there now (IIRC) are Price, King Felix, and Verlander. And with them it's mainly cause of their health. Verlander has something going wonky lately though. Not sure what. May be mechanics, may be hitters being used to him, may be in between his ears. Velocity is still there though.
Click to expand...

Zeet, you are my little bro that I love. And being a catcher like AJ size I can understand your viewpoint, but some of us who played baseball like, we can tell things just like you. Gilesfan said he has family where I came from. He can ask his family members about Finley and Shumpert (who dated my cousin, who to this day regretted dumping him because she thought she was Beyonce), I played with them both on the traveling teams. I played along side both 3rd/LF but I was the younger of the group. I was not on their level (LOL) mechanically wise, but athletically better than both, but basketball was my calling so I quit. Mechanics on a pitcher grows through maturation some will change some don't. We do not know if they are willing to listen (Hanson) or will (Wisler) because I saw some Mad Dog like command from him in that game...his first effing game. Not like he wanted to strike them out, just get them out with any means necessary with minimum effort....aka Mad Dog. Mechanics be damned in that scenario.
 
chop2chip said:
Speaking of Justin, he's having a season much like the ones we were accustomed to. Three weeks ago he looked like he was on pace to hit 35 home runs and have an all around career season. Today, his numbers are right in line with what he did in Atlanta.

I can't quite think of another hitter that would oscillate as much between red fire hot and ice blue cold as much as him.
Click to expand...

Andruw was like that. Maybe not to the degree that Justin is though.
 
If you couldn't see the flaw in Tommy Hanson's mechanics when he was pitching live or on TV, you're zeets.

Minor I've always felt was a matter of time. Teheran is due for shoulder problems soon.
 
Heywood said:
If you couldn't see the flaw in Tommy Hanson's mechanics when he was pitching live or on TV, you're zeets.

Minor I've always felt was a matter of time. Teheran is due for shoulder problems soon.
Click to expand...

You've proven (as my sig indicates) you have something you're looking for in mechanics that's probably not that important.And for you I think it's because you're looking for more of a fluid winder. Less of someone who has a break at times where what you lead up to isn't necessary. For Hanson his hitch could have been just wasteful and not poor mechanically but it was poor mechanically.
 
thethe said:
Not sure why we would think that. Ever since Freddi was sent to the principals office and played Jace everyday he has been awesome. From the point on he is pacing at around a 5WAR season.
Click to expand...

Look at his minor league stats. That's how you'll tell.

Look at the projections, they all tell the same story. He's likely headed for some regression. He is his best case scenario, and while there is the chance he could keep it up at that level, what are the odds of that happening?
 
zitothebrave said:
Look at his minor league stats. That's how you'll tell.

Look at the projections, they all tell the same story. He's likely headed for some regression. He is his best case scenario, and while there is the chance he could keep it up at that level, what are the odds of that happening?
Click to expand...

Thats just a safe response. Because even if he doesn't regress than you will say he is just an outlier. Just admit that you were wrong about Jace and move on sir.
 
thethe said:
Thats just a safe response. Because even if he doesn't regress than you will say he is just an outlier. Just admit that you were wrong about Jace and move on sir.
Click to expand...

What's there to admit I was wrong about? I figured he'd be about a 90-95 wRC+ player with good defense. He's exceeded it offensively, He isn't likely to continue that.

His BABIP is way too high, and his power is a bit too high. They'll both liekly come down.
 
zitothebrave said:
What's there to admit I was wrong about? I figured he'd be about a 90-95 wRC+ player with good defense. He's exceeded it offensively, He isn't likely to continue that.

His BABIP is way too high, and his power is a bit too high. They'll both liekly come down.
Click to expand...

Please tell me why his power is a bit too high?

You realize that you said early in the year that he is a worse version of TLS right?
 
thethe said:
Please tell me why his power is a bit too high?

You realize that you said early in the year that he is a worse version of TLS right?
Click to expand...

No I said offensively he's like TLS without his BABIP skills and has worse power. Defensively I said he'd be better and in the base paths he'd be better.

As far as why. Look at the minors. His minor league career iso was .124, the only levels he showed power were A+ and AAA. That is the key to his overall numbers. Cal and PCL are 2 of the most offensive and power friendly leagues out there and often inflate those numbers.
 
zitothebrave said:
No I said offensively he's like TLS without his BABIP skills and has worse power. Defensively I said he'd be better and in the base paths he'd be better.

As far as why. Look at the minors. His minor league career iso was .124, the only levels he showed power were A+ and AAA. That is the key to his overall numbers. Cal and PCL are 2 of the most offensive and power friendly leagues out there and often inflate those numbers.
Click to expand...

And what is the last tool to typically develop?
 
thethe said:
And what is the last tool to typically develop?
Click to expand...

If that was the case you'd see a major discrepancy.

Ryan howard came into the majors around the same age as Peterson, his minorleague career iso was .250 his major league his major league .260. That's with a different shift mind you as well of Howard moving to a hitter friendly park from less than hitter friendly confines.

I could continue the list, but it would find out that in general your power doesn't peak that late. This isn't the old era when guys were malnourished and poorly prepared for the bigs. Guys now a days are fast tracked and minors are built to churn out top players immediately.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top