GDT- 8/11/18- THE NIGHT OF THE ATTACK OF THE DUVALL

I agree that Venters was the right move. Just saying Biddle has been doing well and was rested. So it was not indefensible to go to him.

You must have become Snit's biggest fan.

Be a numbers-guy or don't be one, none of us know *hit. You guys just can't scream at everybody for not following the numbers and then give someone a pass when they don't.

Does Biddle still have reverse splits? Did AA go get Venters to get lefties out and was he rested?

Then it's indefensible. Otherwise Managers should go with their guts.
 
Last edited:
Biddle has been nails. I have no problem with him getting some high leverage gigs.

With a .234 BABIP who was bound to regress, which we just saw. When you're playing a good team you have to go with what the stats say and not with feelings.
 
You must have become Snit's biggest fan.

Be a numbers-guy or don't be one, none of us know *hit. You guys just can't scream at everybody for not following the numbers and then give someone a pass when they don't.

Does Biddle still have reverse splits? Did AA go get Venters to get lefties out and was he rested?

Then it's indefensible.

Venters was the optimal guy.

But Biddle was not a bad choice because:

1) He has been good
2) He is rested
3) 2 of the first four guys up were righties.

Otoh 2 of the first 3 were lefties. So I preferred Venters, who is also good and rested and has conventional splits.
 
Venters was the optimal guy.

But Biddle was not a bad choice because:

1) He has been good
2) He is rested
3) 2 of the first four guys up were righties.

Otoh 2 of the first 3 were lefties. So I preferred Venters, who is also good and rested and has conventional splits.

Then the move was indefensible.

If you want Managers to run the games by the numbers, of course.
 
Maybe you have him go the 7th, but it's not a bad move to have him pitch in setup, and people are trashing it.

Yes, it wasn't a bad move. Just not the best move. If I were managing tonight, I would have probably pulled Teheran and gone with Brach in the 7th and Venters in the 8th. That's what made the most sense given how the Brewers were set up. It would not have been crazy to let Teheran come back out. But it would be sub-optimal in my view. Just like Biddle over Venters in the 8th was sub-optimal.
 
With a .234 BABIP who was bound to regress, which we just saw. When you're playing a good team you have to go with what the stats say and not with feelings.

I can't make my position any clearer. The optimal move imo was Venters. Biddle was sub-optimal but not indefensible. That's how I see it. There is a world out there between sub-optimal and indefensible.
 
Back
Top