DOB: Braves offseason about to get a lot busier. - Gamel released.

emk418 said:
Samardzija is close to becoming a legitimate top of the rotation starter. I'd go all in to get him.
Click to expand...

I would not go 'all in' per se, but I wouldn't be afraid to pay handsomely. A lot would hinge on whether or not he could be extended.
 
We match up well with the Cubs. The gaps in their rebuilding project are at catcher and pitching. We can help them there. We should offer them Bethancourt plus any three of our minor league pitchers not named Sims or Cabrera.
 
weso1 said:
After giving it some thought I actually think I would trade Heyward for Sale since Heyward might be the least likely to sign a long term deal. Then sign Freeman and Simmons to long term deals and you've got at least 3 top 50 players in their prime for the next 5 years.
Click to expand...

Heresy!!!!!!!
 
PawPawMaxwell said:
Heresy!!!!!!!
Click to expand...

Not so much heresy as questionable in the sense we add a pitcher (while already having 5 solid starting pitchers) while creating a hole in the OF (where we do not have a replacement). It might make sense but only if there is a second trade to get an outfielder. Maybe we then flip a pitcher to a team with extra outfielders (such as the Dodgers).
 
weso1 said:
After giving it some thought I actually think I would trade Heyward for Sale since Heyward might be the least likely to sign a long term deal. Then sign Freeman and Simmons to long term deals and you've got at least 3 top 50 players in their prime for the next 5 years.
Click to expand...

Mentioned this last year, i dont see him signing an extension with us, so might as well get some value for him.

Instead of watch him walk for a pick in the 30-40's in 2 years.
 
Consider: Sale is LH. So are Minor and Wood.

Would that portend anything? Trumbo has played the OF. Ibanez can play LF. Gattis didnt hurt us in LF contrary to some arguments we get.

I would think Sale would require much more than just Heyward and truthfully we dont have that much to offer.
 
nsacpi said:
We match up well with the Cubs. The gaps in their rebuilding project are at catcher and pitching. We can help them there. We should offer them Bethancourt plus any three of our minor league pitchers not named Sims or Cabrera.
Click to expand...

They might take Uggla. They have Darwin Barney at 2b, who sucks,and could possibly sample the kool aid that Uggs will rebound in the smaller ballpark (not true, when he hits it, its gone). We'd have to eat some $, but everybody knows that already. Maybe Beth, Graham, Popeye, and $$$.
 
PawPawMaxwell said:
Consider: Sale is LH. So are Minor and Wood.

Would that portend anything? Trumbo has played the OF. Ibanez can play LF. Gattis didnt hurt us in LF contrary to some arguments we get.

I would think Sale would require much more than just Heyward and truthfully we dont have that much to offer.
Click to expand...

Wood would be in a package for Sale, i think.
 
PawPawMaxwell said:
Consider: Sale is LH. So are Minor and Wood.

Would that portend anything? Trumbo has played the OF. Ibanez can play LF. Gattis didnt hurt us in LF contrary to some arguments we get.

I would think Sale would require much more than just Heyward and truthfully we dont have that much to offer.
Click to expand...

Does Heyward for Sale, and Minor for Trumbo leave us better?
 
What about...

Wood, Northcraft, Martin, Terdo, Varvaro for Russell and Samadizja.
 
sturg33 said:
I think Samardzija would be the perfect pitcher for McDowell to mold.
Click to expand...

I've been one of the few interested in going to get Samardzija for a while (before the deadline the last two years as a matter of fact). I'd agree that he's the type of guy that McDowell would be a good fit for - he's been really good with coaxing that "next step" from Minor, Medlen, and Teheran thus far.

That said, I don't think Sale wouldn't be a fit because he's a LHP, nor do I think he's going to require Heyward in return. I actually think we match up pretty well with the Southsiders. While Wood/Bethancourt/Sims/Peraza isn't likely enough to get Price, I wouldn't hesitate to make the same offer for Sale, and could be convinced to include another "B" arm to land him.
 
clvclv said:
I've been one of the few interested in going to get Samardzija for a while (before the deadline the last two years as a matter of fact). I'd agree that he's the type of guy that McDowell would be a good fit for - he's been really good with coaxing that "next step" from Minor, Medlen, and Teheran thus far.

That said, I don't think Sale wouldn't be a fit because he's a LHP, nor do I think he's going to require Heyward in return. I actually think we match up pretty well with the Southsiders. While Wood/Bethancourt/Sims/Peraza isn't likely enough to get Price, I wouldn't hesitate to make the same offer for Sale, and could be convinced to include another "B" arm to land him.
Click to expand...

Sims is untouchable.
 
Heyward said:
What about...

Wood, Northcraft, Martin, Terdo, Varvaro for Russell and Samadizja.
Click to expand...

Northcraft, Martin, Terdoslavich, and Varvaro have very little trade value - they're throw-ins.

That would work if Theo and Jed are trying to get fired.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top