Grandal, Brantley, Camargo with Asdrubal on the bench
Vs
Mac, Markakis, JD with Camargo on the bench and not losing a pick in the 60s, plus whatever they add around the edges
I know which I would have preferred.
To be fair, both Brantley and Grandal signed for significantly less than expected (especially Grandal). A better comparison would likely be Cutch and Ramos, imo. I guess you can argue AA should have waited out the market on Brantley and Grandal guys, but that's with the benefit of hindsight.