Confirmation Bias, Privilege, Media Manipulation, and a QB

BedellBrave

It's OVER 5,000!
Not quite sure where to put this - so I'll put it here.

Let me say this out front:

1. The Broncos flat out beat the Panthers.
2. Cam Newton could have handled the postgame far better.
3. Fans are fans - they can be irrational homers and haters. Got it.

Those caveats out of the way, I'll say that reading, listening and watching how critics of Cam Newton have responded to him throughout the year and how the media has played him both up and then down, has been helpful. Here's what I'm seeing:

1. Confirmation bias - we see what we want to see to confirm our already held opinions. For example, there's one photo of Coach Rivera and Cam during the singing of the National Anthem (and btw Lady gaga actually did a great job) and folks are critiquing it. Rivera has his hand over his heart. Newton doesn't. Therefore Newton has to be an unpatriotic thug. Right? But I seem to recall while watching it, Newton wasn't being disrespectful, he actually seemed to be listening, maybe even mouthing the words as Gaga sang. That's the way I took it. Reminds me of the photos taken of politicians we don't like standing on podiums with other politicians who've gotten their hands over their hearts a split second or two before the ones we don't like did and the photo is taken at that precise moment. Then is goes viral showing us what we want to see.

2. Media Manipulation - that shows to me at least, how easily we can be manipulated. It's gutter stuff - but that's where we reside too often when it's someone we don't like. And it's all about ratings, clicks, and the bucks for the media.

3. Context matters - and this builds upon the first two points. Take the press conference where admittedly Newton was petulant - or maybe better put, pissed. Yet, as we now know, those pressers were going on in the same room - and as he has his and you listen carefully to the audio you hear Harris's nearby and Harris is making the point that they game planned to make Newton throw - and lose - and Newton is hearing all that. Yes, I'd wished he had of sucked it up better and responded better and more graciously, but the larger context makes it more understandable. But again, he's my QB.

4. Racism - yeah, I'm going there. This year has been helpful for me, and I think many in this area, we've seen tons of criticism of his exuberance, his dancing, and Superman poses, and selfies, etc., and frankly, so much of it just seems to be aimed at him because he's black and not acting like white folks think a superstar should act. Maybe I'm just being a homer. Or maybe, there's more truth to this than we'd like to admit... I wonder if a white QB who keeps himself out of trouble off the field played like Newton does, if he'd receive the same amount of vitriol thrown his way...

Here's hoping he continues to be a guy who plays with passion - win or lose.
 
a lot of the **** on Newton is a hangover effect from the whole Auburn/recruitment stuff. People don't forget about that. College football is bigger than the NFL down south. They were just waiting for a reason to hate on him again.

many black players have critiqued and called Newton out for his post game press conference walk out. Leaders don't walk out like that. He should had sucked it up.
 
There's over-reporting of the silly and under-reporting of the important.

Part of this is the crazy overhype of the SB (Gotta say something!) and that the reality of the game, that both defenses were dominating, didn't match the narrative of superstar black QB becoming King doing his dab dance and ratings loving it. When that didn't happen the media had to improvise, which they are good at.

Cam's press conference behavior didn't help him. Better to not show at all that to sit there sulking like a teenager. I blame part of that on his coach. It's his job to remind his players to be magnanimous in defeat.
 
His behavior for much of the game was petulant. The no calls or missed call flopping around on the ground over them... Just doesn't mesh with his persona he puts out there daily. If you are going to brand yourself as a confident machismo with dances and a brand.... You can't act like he did. You can't pull that . The lack of diving for the ball was bigger to me that the presser. He's gonna have to answer to teammates for that and they are gonna have to believe him.

Deadspin had a pretty good article on this Bedell.

http://deadspin.com/cam-****ing-blew-it-1757768173
 
When Belichik or Popovich act this way in post game pressers they are called "competitive"

As far as the fumble, looked to me like he didn't think he could get it from where he was. IF not mistaken, after the ball squirted out of the Broncos recoverer, didn't Cam jump into that pile ?

Cam runs goal line blasts, I don't think he was scared.
Please
 
When Belichik or Popovich act this way in post game pressers they are called "competitive"

As far as the fumble, looked to me like he didn't think he could get it from where he was. IF not mistaken, after the ball squirted out of the Broncos recoverer, didn't Cam jump into that pile ?

Cam runs goal line blasts, I don't think he was scared.
Please

They act the same way all the time and mocked for it. I don't think the two are related.

And on the fumble, it looked like he had the best chance of anyone.... And with the SB on the line.... Find out. You can't back away.
 
BTW I probably fall into the category of one of the guys who "hates" Cam. I don't really hate him. I made fun of him relentlessly when he was at Auburn because it was fun to piss off gr8. I ripped him in Carolina because they're a division opponent. He's a solid QB. He's probably the best running QB we've seen since Randall Cunningham. But his flaws were in full view in the Super Bowl when he was missing wide open receivers on reads and making slightly errant passes. That works fine when you're facing teams like the Saints, but when you're facing Denver, it isn't so good. They're a team you have to maximize your chances against and missing wide open receivers or delivering a ball slightly behind a man isn't gonna cut it.

Personally I find his playful behavior to be a bit refreshing. It's fun to see guys having fun and playing football. It's a game that these guys are gonna be traumatically injured and suffer long term health consequences from. Why not let them have fun? Why make them be serious?
 
They act the same way all the time and mocked for it. I don't think the two are related.

And on the fumble, it looked like he had the best chance of anyone.... And with the SB on the line.... Find out. You can't back away.

SB wasn't on the line. If you had watched it to that point it was obvious it wasn't.

Looked to me like he was waiting for it to bounce out - which it often does before the final scrum. Watching him play throughout the year and watching him play with a broken back last year after the car wreck, let's just say, it's really hard to chalk his actions up to fear.

But even assuming it was - be honest - the Broncos were - they were really going to hurt him if he was in a scrum. Intended to. Planned to.
 
^^^ My point number 3. The context wasn't made obvious by the media, thus manipulating the story, which in turn confirmed folks' bias. Now, folks have to ask why they are biased against him. Course it'll never be because "I'm a racist." Nope.

Now we've got folks complaining that he shows any negative emotion period. Smh.

No, I made that post fully knowing that he walked out because he heard Harris chirping in his ear about the whole game right behind the curtain. I don't really care he walked out, but just explain it? Just say very simply, "im gonna excuse myself while this guy gives his interview " or something.

The fumbles the thing though. Not much defense on that.
 
They act the same way all the time and mocked for it. I don't think the two are related.

And on the fumble, it looked like he had the best chance of anyone.... And with the SB on the line.... Find out. You can't back away.

"Mocked"? No, they are "tough" and "surly" and that's all good for old white guys...
 
^^^ My point number 3. The context wasn't made obvious by the media, thus manipulating the story, which in turn confirmed folks' bias. Now, folks have to ask why they are biased against him. Course it'll never be because "I'm a racist." Nope.

Now we've got folks complaining that he shows any negative emotion period. Smh.

I mean you saw it in the Falcons game, Cam is a "poor sport" but he's hardly alone in the NFL. I can't think of many players who're gracious in defeat aside from for show. SOme don't even attempt to show it. I mean Peyton didn't congratulate any Saints players after they won. The headlines weren't runnign around calling him a poor sport.

FWIW I do think the media is trying to bring Cam down. It's gonna force me to be a fan of a rival player. I don't want to do that but Cam is generally a good guy, he hasn't been tied to anything criminal yet, he doesn't get shat on by opponents. Sure a few guys don't like him, but that's true of any player in the NFL. I haven't seen anything to vilify Cam. Is he more emotional than some other players? Yes. Is that bad thing? No.
 
SB wasn't on the line. If you had watched it to that point it was obvious it wasn't.

Looked to me like he was waiting for it to bounce out - which it often does before the final scrum. Watching him play throughout the year and watching him play with a broken back last year after the car wreck, let's just say, it's really hard to chalk his actions up to fear.

But even assuming it was - be honest - the Broncos were - they were really going to hurt him if he was in a scrum. Intended to. Planned to.

Sure they did. No question. It didn't look to me he was waiting for it to bounce out...which is SOMETIMES does. It looked like he saw the ball and people coming and said, NOPE. Not today. It was a one score game. I have watched enough NFL to know it isn't over in a one score game until the clock shows 0's.

I get it, he is your boy and all. But that's a tough one Bedell.
 
I mean you saw it in the Falcons game, Cam is a "poor sport" but he's hardly alone in the NFL. I can't think of many players who're gracious in defeat aside from for show. SOme don't even attempt to show it. I mean Peyton didn't congratulate any Saints players after they won. The headlines weren't runnign around calling him a poor sport.

FWIW I do think the media is trying to bring Cam down. It's gonna force me to be a fan of a rival player. I don't want to do that but Cam is generally a good guy, he hasn't been tied to anything criminal yet, he doesn't get shat on by opponents. Sure a few guys don't like him, but that's true of any player in the NFL. I haven't seen anything to vilify Cam. Is he more emotional than some other players? Yes. Is that bad thing? No.

He's not a white robot. He's a "thug" yada, yada. We know the drill now.

He's a big kid, a goof ball, who loves to play, hates losing, and loves kids. He's a good dude. But note - he's in the sights - not Talib, or others. Sickening to me.
 
Looking at the video the ball appears to be inches from his left foot. With momentum etc, he had no angle. Had he dove --- he would have missed by 4'
The video also shows him diving into the scrum when the ball squirted loose

..................
 
Cam can't dance all over the field when he is winning (which I have no issues with) and then cry like a baby and refuse to answer questions when he loses. For two weeks, he begged for the spotlight... embraced it, and when the moment got too big for him, he acted like a child.

And yes, the non-dive for the fumble was the worst moment of his night. Down 6, he had the best chance for the ball, and he consciously chose to not dive for it.
 
He's not a white robot. He's a "thug" yada, yada. We know the drill now.

He's a big kid, a goof ball, who loves to play, hates losing, and loves kids. He's a good dude. But note - he's in the sights - not Talib, or others. Sickening to me.

Talib should be vilified. He is not a guy I'd want on my team. He's incredibly talented. But remember there's a reason the Bucs gave him up to the Pats for only a 4th round pick.
 
He's not a white robot. He's a "thug" yada, yada. We know the drill now.

He's a big kid, a goof ball, who loves to play, hates losing, and loves kids. He's a good dude. But note - he's in the sights - not Talib, or others. Sickening to me.

Talib's not a QB... don't be purposefully dense
 
"Mocked"? No, they are "tough" and "surly" and that's all good for old white guys...

People call BB the Grumblelord or something. He is like that all the time and there are 57's memes about them. They are mocked because they are so unfriendly. The worst people call Cam is Scam because of his Auburn scandal. I don't think any of this is a big deal long term either. The most confident guy in the league got humbled. Its a thing.

And once again...Pops and BB are like that 24/7. It isn't anything different for them. They aren't superman at one point, and then a recluse the next. They don't put themselves in front of the camera every chance they get sometimes, then sulk away when it isn't convenient.

This isn't a big deal, just a short storyline. No big deal.
 
Back
Top