Getting An Early Start - GDT 10/4/2013: LA (Zack Stinky) @ ATL (Mike MAJOR!) Game 2

gilesfan said:
And take a right hander on the mound, defense, and base running into consideration.
Click to expand...

But Schafer put up those August and September numbers while primarily facing righties. Imagine if he was facing lefties also? He only has 31 AB vs lefties on the year.
 
NYCBrave said:
But Schafer put up those August and September numbers while primarily facing righties. Imagine if he was facing lefties also? He only has 31 AB vs lefties on the year.
Click to expand...

Schafer sucked down the stretch, hardly news. So did Gattis though.

In one case Fredi chose defense when he had to choose between 2 impotent bats (uggla and Johnson) on the other he chose the bat, it's a baffling inconsistency, especially when Uggla has much more history than Gattis.
 
gilesfan said:
Against a lefty.

And cost runs in the field and got out on the bases.
Click to expand...

Schafer has sucked butt in the second half, huge regression.

While Gattis cost us a run in the field, I blame that on Mac and Meds, should of walked Ellis with the pitcher on deck.

The base running mistake was pretty bad though.

Not sure it mattered, Kershaw was just too nasty.
 
If we're going defense and base running, go with the Uptons and Heyward.

Since its likely we won't do much vs Greinke in all likelyhood.
 
You are still putting a guy out there that is a huge liability in the field. He's also not going to give you a thing on the bases. Yes, he always has the potential to hit a homer, but what are the odds against a guy like Greinke?

So, you put a guy with low chance of getting on base (
 
As much as it sucks to take out Gattis' bat, Schafer is still 5-11 against Greinke, a RHP, and should at least be brought into pinch-hit first if nothing else.
 
Dunit24 said:
Gattis > Schafer

Not even a question
Click to expand...

Agreed but this is likely going to be a low scoring game, or if we are going to win, it should.

Runs are at a premium this series, can't give runs away with bad defense, base running, etc.

I would start BJ if we are going with that.
 
Nothing wrong with having Gattis in the lineup if you have him batting where he should. He is one of those guys (power and nothing else positive) you have to hit #6-8 and count on people being on base when he hits his homer. Jason, Upton, and Freeman get on base too often to have Gattis making an out over 70% of the time.
 
LOL....some of you keep saying runs will be at a premium and then you want to take a hitter (Gattis) out of the lineup who is counted on to supply those runs (for an offense that is struggling). On very few occasions will having a plodding leftfielder cost you anything defensively. I can vaguely think of 1 or 2 times during the season where he hurt us defensively. But I can think of many times where he was the difference offensively. He makes the plays he's supposed to make 99% of the time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top