You can also make the argument Moore had been there almost a decade before they were even above .500, several top 3 picks later.
AA took over for Ricciardi and got them to new heights in less time.
You could. Arguments are always there to be made.
You could also argue that the Royals carried payrolls of
07 67m
08 58m
09 71m
10 72m
11 36m (lowest in baseball)
12 60 m
13 81 million (the turn)
14 92 m
15 113 m
You would also want to consider that during the bulk of that time the Tigers were a top 10 payroll and usually a top 5 and that the White Sox were usually easily over 100 million, that the Twins generally cared more payroll, and that Cleveland was generally at last in the same ball park.
The last playoff appearance for the Royals was 1985 and Moore took over the franchise cold when it losing 100 games.
Jays payrolls from 2012 forward were 95m, 117m, 132m,122m,126m,159m.
.....
Given that AA cashed in prospects and spent a lot of money, at time some suggest unwisely, it's an open question as to whether making two WS in KC is better or worse than making two ALCS in Toronto when the AL East was relatively down.
---Also, AA is not particularly credited with being an analytics guy. I'm not sure that working for the Dodgers made him one.
Either way, he seems to share a lot of philosophies with Coppy though we never saw Coppy spend money or make go for it trades, so hard to really evaluate that.
.......
I don't think it matters much, but i don't get the disdain for Moore. He won the WS in Kansas City. And maybe another Series. It wasn't a fluke of bounces. They built a really good team. Maybe they could do it again. I don't know. But I don't really dismiss success just because its convenient.