MadduxFanII
Swallowed by Mark Bowman
The bigger question with Riley—if the team is serious about keeping a killer infield around for the next 7+ years—is what is reasonable to offer as an extension to him right now. I'd be hesitant, given his previous struggles, and the fact he's coming off a banner year; but, if you think even 80% of that performance is sustainable, now is the time to extent to maximize value.
I'm OK going year-to-year with Riley. He's surpassed my expectations at every step in his career, and kudos to him for that, but I don't see him aging well. Get as much production as you can from him in his cheap years, then move on.