Southcack77
Well-known member
Yah its hard to get excited about any of the real options here. I'd stay furthest away from Wieters for the reasons you mentioned... he's still living basically on hype from when he was the big can't miss prospect... he will get paid way more than he's ever been or ever will be worth. Especially since he's not much of a defender. Hard not to love what Ramos has done this year, but man what a prolific injury history. He's still fairly young... 29 next year, but with his injury history 29 sounds pretty old. He's also never had a performance remotely close to this and has a .353 BABIP... not sure about his defensive skills but all those red flags on offense just scream stay away IMO. He's going to get paid a ton more than he's worth. Not excited about Norris at all... love Castro's defense and has some power upside, especially if platooned. With Flowers around he may be the best option. I'm okay with McCann if we can get him on the cheap, but I am very hesitant to give much talent for him given he's shown signs of decline in the past 3 years and he's getting towards the rapid decline stage most catchers face.
the more I think about free agent options, the more I think that McCann isn't such a bad idea if they don't have give up anything and don't have to guarantee that third year option.
Two years is a pretty good bridge and I don't think signing him stops them from looking for a controllable guy somewhere.