Quintana, or a pitcher like him, might make the Braves a contender at the deadline next year. That would be the time to pull the trigger on acquiring a controllable #2...not now.
Official 2017 Trade Deadilne Thread
- Thread starter Oklahomabrave
- Start date
Quintana, or a pitcher like him, might make the Braves a contender at the deadline next year. That would be the time to pull the trigger on acquiring a controllable #2...not now.
Exactly right. Just too early.
Horsehide Harry
<B>Mr. Free Trade</B>
I have to hope that the FO is allowing themselves to be used by the Chisox to drive up the price for Q which in turn pulls through a higher price for Teheran.
It's the only thing that makes any sense at all to me. As others have said, the Chisox have to get some bats back and the Braves don't have bats to give.
I guess I would do an Albies plus Riley, Fried and Touki trade where the Braves obviously win (Chisox wouldn't do it), but only if I knew I could turn around and trade him to a team like the Cubs for something along the lines of Jimenez, Cease and De La Cruz - essentially shuffling the prospect deck. I would do it because I value Jimenez greater than Albies since Jimenez would likely bring a more productive bat as opposed to a table setting bat. 2B are easier to find than top shelf OF.
It's the only thing that makes any sense at all to me. As others have said, the Chisox have to get some bats back and the Braves don't have bats to give.
I guess I would do an Albies plus Riley, Fried and Touki trade where the Braves obviously win (Chisox wouldn't do it), but only if I knew I could turn around and trade him to a team like the Cubs for something along the lines of Jimenez, Cease and De La Cruz - essentially shuffling the prospect deck. I would do it because I value Jimenez greater than Albies since Jimenez would likely bring a more productive bat as opposed to a table setting bat. 2B are easier to find than top shelf OF.
Just throwing *hit out there - slow afternoon when I had a sec to poke my head in. Was better than a discussion about Freeman's lack of range at 3B that we all recognized before he played over there IMO.
Two pitchers won't magically make us legit contenders, especially when one of them is a middle reliever. But they do help make us close. Swarzak helps stabilize the pen while Viz is on the DL. Quintana obviously helps to stabilize the rotation. Both additions benefit the 2018 team as well.
The offense is pretty good. Not great obviously, but good enough to win a bunch of games if we had better pitching. And we hopefully get a good boost from S-Rod in the 2nd half as well. Assuming that trade went down, being a legit contender the rest of the way would require JT to keep up his recent form, Quintana to pitch considerably better in the NL, and for Folty to continue to improve and not regress. I feel pretty confident between Newcomb, Garcia, and Dickey that we can get about league average production from some combination the rest of the way. And obviously staying mostly injury free.
zbhargrove
Well-known member
Can't argue with that.
Wait a sec...wasn't it the blackjack dealer that told us how big an idiot Coppy is???
Not that anyone HERE disagrees with this statement, but you are aware that Coppy's job is ultimately dependent on making the fans happy and the vast majority of them likely don't recognize any of those names, right???
You are such an idiot. It's impressive how stupid you are. Truly impressive.
ixiXSolidXixi
Called Up to the Major Leagues
I dont get why we want Quintana when he had just a winning season with 13-12 record. He had a great ERA but he is not even a ACE.
CrimsonCowboy
Moderator
I still don't believe the Braves will seek a TOR type pitcher until the offseason. I honestly don't see a big deal from the Braves before the deadline. Johnson and Motte will be asked about because relievers are coveted by contenders. We may see offers for Teheran (Astros, Brewers, Yankees, Royals possibilities), but that is 50/50 at best.
cajunrevenge
Well-known member
Southcack77
Well-known member
I don't think the price on these guys is likely to drop for any reason other than they have less control or blow up.
Cheap, good pitching will always carry a price and if the package is bearable now might as well do it.
I'm not sure whether there are similar pitchers to Archer coming available so it might be a somewhat unique opportunity. Or perhaps not.
Archer has a ton of control and the braves shouod absolutely be willing to give up any of their pitching prospects -- the question would be how much else it would cost.