Official pre-Draft thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Considering the Braves can find a cheap guy in every single offseason to fill the spot a busted Lewis would take, I say go for absolute maximum upside. The draft is the only way the Braves are going to be able to acquire a 900+ OPS monster for the middle of their lineup.

I fully agree. I thought you had said you wanted Lewis, though.

Anyway, I think the four guys with the highest upside in this draft are Greene, Gore, Beck, and Adell. So I want one of those 4.
 
I fully agree. I thought you had said you wanted Lewis, though.

I would be happy with Lewis. I would be happy with Wright, Greene, Lewis, Gore, Beck or Adell. My preference changes daily based on the latest blurb I read.

I would not be happy with McKay, Bukauskas (sp?), Pratto, or any other low upside player signed to save money.
 
I would be happy with Lewis. I would be happy with Wright, Greene, Lewis, Gore, Beck or Adell. My preference changes daily based on the latest blurb I read.

I would not be happy with McKay, Bukauskas (sp?), Pratto, or any other low upside player signed to save money.

We can agree on that.

Bukauskas I might be able to talk myself into because I don't care as much about height on a pitcher, but yes, we agree.
 
Adell/Beck vs Lewis is floor vs ceiling. If Adell/Beck busts, they are not MLB players. If Lewis busts he is still a bench piece.

So which do you take? The impact hitter that could never even see an MLB pitch, or the guy with less offensive upside but who is much more likely to actually be a big-leaguer?

Considering the Braves can find a cheap guy in every single offseason to fill the spot a busted Lewis would take, I say go for absolute maximum upside. The draft is the only way the Braves are going to be able to acquire a 900+ OPS monster for the middle of their lineup.

I can't disagree with you at all here
 
I would be happy with Lewis. I would be happy with Wright, Greene, Lewis, Gore, Beck or Adell. My preference changes daily based on the latest blurb I read.

I would not be happy with McKay, Bukauskas (sp?), Pratto, or any other low upside player signed to save money.

Agree with everything here too
 
The thing that makes me interested in Lewis is the fact that he could be a Francisco Lindor type... except faster... but he could also bust hard and be a utility guy.
 
Considering the Braves can find a cheap guy in every single offseason to fill the spot a busted Lewis would take, I say go for absolute maximum upside. The draft is the only way the Braves are going to be able to acquire a 900+ OPS monster for the middle of their lineup.

Dude. We have Kemp.
 
I doubt we go the route of Adell, but man... his upside sure is tantalizing

I think he has the highest upside in the draft, and I think he's probably my preference if I had to choose someone. I agree that I doubt we go that route, we'll likely take Beck over him if we go HS bat, and I'm fine with that. But yes, if he hits, you're talking elite of the elite.
 
I agree with most of you that Gore, Beck, Wright, and Lewis are my preferences and at least 2 of them will probably be available. With the way our pitching has performed in the minors this year I'd prefer a hitter.
 
If Brent Rooker falls to Round 3, I hope we're all over him. I might even take a shot in Round 2. I don't care that much where he plays defensively, the bat is so legit.
 
Adell/Beck vs Lewis is floor vs ceiling. If Adell/Beck busts, they are not MLB players. If Lewis busts he is still a bench piece.

So which do you take? The impact hitter that could never even see an MLB pitch, or the guy with less offensive upside but who is much more likely to actually be a big-leaguer?

Considering the Braves can find a cheap guy in every single offseason to fill the spot a busted Lewis would take, I say go for absolute maximum upside. The draft is the only way the Braves are going to be able to acquire a 900+ OPS monster for the middle of their lineup.

I completely agree with your argument here.
 
Another so-so start for McKay with velocity dipping again near the end of it.

The good news is he hit a grand slam. I'm hoping he has a strong two weeks. The board sets up pretty well for us if someone takes him in the top four.
 
MLB Pipeline's updated mock goes Wright-Greene-Gore-McKay. They have us passing on the HS bats (Lewis, Beck, Adell) taking Adam Haseley at 5: http://m.mlb.com/news/article/232496282/jim-callis-mock-projection-2017-mlb-draft/?topicid=151437456

5. Braves: Adam Haseley, OF, Virginia
Atlanta's scouting department would be thrilled to get Wright if McKay goes No. 1 and Tampa Bay looks elsewhere. In this scenario, the Braves' choice figures to come down to Haseley or Lewis. They're also the first club that might pop Texas high school right-hander Shane Baz, and it's also possible that they'd look for a discount deal to shift extra money to later picks.
 
Interesting take. I think some of the college bats will have late helium as their seasons wind down like Senzel did last year.
 
Another so-so start for McKay with velocity dipping again near the end of it.

The good news is he hit a grand slam. I'm hoping he has a strong two weeks. The board sets up pretty well for us if someone takes him in the top four.

I honestly kind of hope he falls. I don't really want Lewis and I seriously doubt we would take McKay, so it would set up nicely for us to fall into Beck or Adell if the top 4 is Wright-Greene-Gore-Lewis.

Haseley is intriguing, but I like the HS bats more.
 
I hope we don't do a cheap deal this year with our 5th pick. Just take BPA bc there are a lot of teams that have more money to spend than us. If one of Lewis, Gore, Wright is there and we pass somebody needs a nut punch.
 
Haseley .399/.498/.683 208 AB 14 HR 41/20 (BB/K) 10/14 SB.

Somewhat successful pitcher at college level with FB perhaps touching 90. Definite draft as hitter. I think the weight of what I've read suggests his defense would probably play a little better in a corner, but could possibly handle center. I think that makes him a little bit of a tweener/possibl fourth OF. If his power does not continue moving up it seems a little light.

Would not be my preference, but it seems like a bet on his power. I like the apparent hit tool.

Still, Maybe I'm trying to force fit big potential into a bad draft, but I'd rather take the tools of an Adell and Beck and roll the dice on what they become as far as OF goes.
 
Haseley

Scouting grades, per MLB Pipeline

Hit: 55 | Power: 45 | Run: 55 | Arm: 50 | Field: 55 | Overall: 55
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top