REAL FOOTBALL Thread

[zitothebrave]

LMAO, no he wouldn't. Great Qbs are great QBs, regardless of coach. Stafford was a easily a top 10 QB before coming to the Rams. He's had 2 amazing years in LA and the rest of the time his stats have been on par with what they were in Detroit (honestly a little worse). He still has a great arm even at 38 that allows him to make throws into tight windows.

He is far more talented than Ryan ever was which is why his career didn't go south as he got older. Unlike Ryan who fell off a cliff once his talent faded. It was blatantly obvious Ryan was cooked after 2020. His throws noticeably lacked zip.

LMAO what are you talking about?

 

[zitothebrave]

Matt Ryan is Jared Goff

Stafford is Stafford

If Jared Goff is capable of winning an MVP in the same era as Brees, Brady, Rodgers, etc. you'd have a point.

 

[zitothebrave]

You keep bringing this up, which is stupid. Douglas was a 1 receiver because of volume in a year where Julio was out for most of the year and Roddy White was clearly in decline. He had 132 targers. I hope to God he could break 1k with that many targets. Ryan Tannehill made Brain Hartline a 2 time 1k yard receiver. I guess Tanne is an amazing QB too.

Calvin Ridley was a no. 1 WR. Ryan didn't make him into anything.

Kupp and Puka are the equivalent of Julian Edelman and Wes Welker. They are talented guys, but they are what they are because of who was throwing them the ball. You wouldn't know either of their names if they were drafted by the Bears or Cardinals or someone like that.

My dude, you're absolutely off your fucking rocker.

Ridley went to Jacksonville and Tennessee and what happened? He regressed into a mid receiver.

Calling Kupp and Puka equivalent to Edelman and Welker is hilarious. First Welker isn't comparable to Edelman, Welker wa sa much better receiver than Edelman. But you do realize that Kupp and Puka are YAC machines. They're beasts at making catches and getting more yards after catch. Edelman was never that. Edelman was like a short Travis Kelce, he was there to get open and catch the ball.

Kupp was a great receiver with Goff too, he just wasn't healthy.

 

[zitothebrave]

Yup. Ryan was loaded every single season until the end.

Stafford had Tron and basically no one else until Golden Tate arrived. And they only played together for 2 seasons. Detroit also had garbage rushing games nearly every year Stafford was there. So it was mostly just Calvin Johnson and no one else until Tate showed up. I suppose Brandon Pettigrew was reliable, but he was far from a top tier tight end.

Ryan had one top end TE. Then he had Levine Toilolo, Jacob Tamme, Austin Hooper, Hayden Hurst, and Kyle Pitts.

 

[sturg33]

If Jared Goff is capable of winning an MVP in the same era as Brees, Brady, Rodgers, etc. you'd have a point.

Well, in 2024 Lions offense scored 33.2 points and averaged 409 yards per game. In 2016 Falcons averaged 33.8 and 415 yards

 

[zitothebrave]

Well, in 2024 Lions offense scored 33.2 points and averaged 409 yards per game. In 2016 Falcons averaged 33.8 and 415 yards

Jared Goff (2024-2024) vs. Matt Ryan (2016-2016): Head-to-Head Stats Comparison | Stathead

Compare Players: Check out the head-to-head stats of Jared Goff (2024-2024) and Matt Ryan (2016-2016) including their awards, honors, championships, playoff and regular season stats, and much more on Stathead

www.sports-reference.com

In 1 less game Ryan had 300 more yards, 1 More TD 5 less INTs Ryan even was a better runner which is hilarious to anyone.

 

[sturg33]

I didn't use counting stats bc there were different number of games... but Goff led an offense just as prolific as Ryan's MVP year

 

[zitothebrave]

I didn't use counting stats bc there were different number of games... but Goff led an offense just as prolific as Ryan's MVP year

Ryan was statistically better in basically every single aspect.

We can even see back on EPA/Play and CPOE back then.

Ryan had a .336 adj EPA/Play and 6.9 CPOE
Goff had a .303 adj EPA/Play and 5.7 CPOE

In every aspect of the game Ryan in 2016 was far superior to Goff in 2024. Goff's offense was buoyed by their running game too which was exceptional. Falcons offense was driven through Ryan.

 

[Carp]

Ryan had one top end TE. Then he had Levine Toilolo, Jacob Tamme, Austin Hooper, Hayden Hurst, and Kyle Pitts.

Ryan had at least 2 of Tony G, Roddy White, Julio Jones, and Calvin Ridley for like 80% of this career.

 

[sturg33]

Ryan was statistically better in basically every single aspect.

We can even see back on EPA/Play and CPOE back then.

Ryan had a .336 adj EPA/Play and 6.9 CPOE
Goff had a .303 adj EPA/Play and 5.7 CPOE

In every aspect of the game Ryan in 2016 was far superior to Goff in 2024. Goff's offense was buoyed by their running game too which was exceptional. Falcons offense was driven through Ryan.

I'm not making the argument that Goff was better than Ryan... just that he had a year very similar to Ryan's best season just last year.

 

[zitothebrave]

Ryan had at least 2 of Tony G, Roddy White, Julio Jones, and Calvin Ridley for like 80% of this career.

You act like Calvin Ridley is some kind of stud. He's at best a poor man's Roddy White.

 

[zitothebrave]

I'm not making the argument that Goff was better than Ryan... just that he had a year very similar to Ryan's best season just last year.

Goff's last year was better than Stafford's this year, so by that logic, you're still saying Ryan>Stafford.

 

[sturg33]

Goff's last year was better than Stafford's this year, so by that logic, you're still saying Ryan>Stafford.

I didn't say Stafford this year was better than Ryan's MVP year. I said Stafford was the MVP this year. You said it was a mediocre RB