The 8th pick it is. I'm interested in the question of whether HS pitchers, HS hitters, college pitcher or college hitters on average provide the most value in this part of the draft. To generate a decent sample I'm going to look at picks 6-10 in the last 8 drafts (2010-2017). Lets start with HS pitchers.
They were: Karsten Williams (did not sign), Archie Bradley, Max Fried, Trey Ball, Phil Bickford (DNS), Braxton Garrett, Matt Manning
The HS hitters were: Delino DeShields, Francisco Lindor, Javier Baez, Albert Almora, Austin Meadows, David Dahl, Alex Jackson, Cornelius Randolph, Austin Beck, Jordan Adell
The college pitchers were: Barrett Loux (DNS), Matt Harvey, Mark Appel (DNS), Andrew Heaney, Aaron Nola, Kyle Freeland, Jeff Hoffman, Tyler Jay, Carson Fulmer, AJ Puk, Carl Quantrill
The college hitters were: Michael Choice, Anthony Rendon, Corey Spangenberg, Colin Moran, Hunter Dozier, Michael Conforto, Andrew Benitendi, Ian Happ, Zach Collins, Pavin Smith, Adam Haseley, Keston Hiura
Which group provided the best value? Interesting that HS pitchers are a bit underrepresented in this part of the draft. A significant percentage of busts in each group.