Southcack77
Well-known member
Dickey is the least likely to be traded of the three as he has an option and if he pitches well that would be a bargain. If he pitches poorly then he won't be worth much at the deadline as you say. Garcia is a real gamble because he's oft-injured and last year wasn't the Garcia he use to be, folks assert well that was just second half but his first half numbers weren't good either. They just weren't bad like his second half. If he stays healthy I wouldn't expect more than a 3.50 ERA and if traded at the deadline I doubt he brings back any more than we gave up for him. Colon is someone you can trade and probably get the best return at the deadline if he keeps pitching well.
I don't think anyone on a one year contract that was acquired for very little is a big gamble, but I'd say Garcia is probably the most likely to pay off in prospects of the three.
there is a thesis for his struggles and he's healthy and entering a contract year. Still, you have to worry sometimes about taking the other side of a bet with the cards.