In your opinion. Facts and opinions are 2 different things. You should have learned that in grade school
Are really comparing actual outcomes to interpretations of outcomes?
In your opinion. Facts and opinions are 2 different things. You should have learned that in grade school
Are really comparing actual outcomes to interpretations of outcomes?
We're comparing interpretations of value. Any stat when you put value on it there's an issue with interpretations. Who's to say that a walk has an exact value? So on so forth. Not to mention even stats like batting average have human interpretation of their outcomes. In 2013 there was 2760 errors or so in baseball (I'm not doing the math of adding up each team's total so it's based on averages, could be higher could be lower don't have the time nor do I care enough) if you want to say that every single one of them was justly called not to mention that every hit was justly called a hit. I can sell you shares in the Brooklyn Bridge.
You are stretching the argument way too wide. There is so much more interpretations when it comes to defensive stats it is even worth discussing. That will hopefully change with field/fx. You know this but as always you like to be argumentative (in a good way and I enjoy it).
It takes him five minutes to get to the bathroom?
Yes he's 3 years younger but I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. Coming into this year Heyward had a 348 WOBA and 119 wrc+ compared to Harpers .359 and 128. Better? Yes. Significantly better? I'm not sure about that.
Harper seems injury prone and really stupid.
Projecting is dangerous. Look what we projected with Heyward after his rookie year... Didn't pan out. Harper seems injury prone and really stupid. He may not turn into what we expect either
Harper seems injury prone and really stupid.
You can't have doubts if he even loves baseball, though.
Matt Williams has those doubts...
Much of that is due to his rookie year; which was 4 years ago. In the 3 years since: .333 wOBA and 111 wrc+
Plus, if you are projecting for the next 3 years, how do you predict their offensive production?
Well ****, that one time he had a sore thumb. And this year he's jumpy bc of the faceguard. Lets just through all that out. He's a .385 wOBA and WRC+ of 150 type of guy for the future!
Or we can stick with facts and not cherry pick. 119 coming into this year and 121 the last two. As is I think Heyward will produce somewhere in that area. As he gets closer to his prime I think those numbers will climb.
And Harper was 137 last year, which should climb as he gets closer to his prime. Which hitter is better?
And Harper was 137 last year, which should climb as he gets closer to his prime. Which hitter is better?
Harper is a better hitter and I've never argued against that however as a baseball player Heyward is better. He does everything well. Harper does not.