2018 Offseason And Targets

Status
Not open for further replies.
Analytics drives a lot of people in baseball crazy, but as this new hire by the Braves show, it is becoming a bigger part of the game and the way decisions are made. But there is still a place for the old school thinking that many have and combined correctly with the analytical way of thinking, it can be a huge help to a team. Obviously, the Braves think the same and I like this hire. The old “Braves Way” now we can say is gone and a new version of it is here.
 
With Kimbrel, its fans being nostalgic more than diving into the performance I believe

Still an elite closer and still has elite velocity. I do understand the reasoning of not investing a lot of dollars into a reliever, but I also think that Kimbrel is exception to the rule just like Chapman or Rivera.
 
To put aside all those clamoring for a Donaldson signing------

"However it may seem from the outside, though, Braves GM Alex Anthopolous made clear today that he doesn’t see a need to seek change in the infield mix. As David O’Brien of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution tweets, the club’s top baseball decisionmaker says that, within the organization, “we feel like we’re set in the infield." "


That's from MLBTR article on Swanson having surgery on wrist
 
This hire is wonderful. Poaching an analytics guy from one of the smartest organizations in baseball is huge. I really hope that this hire points to continuation of a general shift in philosophy that started with the hiring of Anthopoulos. Analytics is the future and I hope the Braves become one of the teams at the forefront
 
To put aside all those clamoring for a Donaldson signing------

"However it may seem from the outside, though, Braves GM Alex Anthopolous made clear today that he doesn’t see a need to seek change in the infield mix. As David O’Brien of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution tweets, the club’s top baseball decisionmaker says that, within the organization, “we feel like we’re set in the infield." "


That's from MLBTR article on Swanson having surgery on wrist

Sticking with Camargo/Riley at 3b until the deadline is probably the correct move.
 
To put aside all those clamoring for a Donaldson signing------

"However it may seem from the outside, though, Braves GM Alex Anthopolous made clear today that he doesn’t see a need to seek change in the infield mix. As David O’Brien of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution tweets, the club’s top baseball decisionmaker says that, within the organization, “we feel like we’re set in the infield." "


That's from MLBTR article on Swanson having surgery on wrist

I still hope that they make a move to acquire a lefty or switch hitter utility player who can provide an ~.800 OPS against RHP. Really, it doesn't even have to be a utility player. It could just be a 3rd baseman and then we could use Camargo to shift around the infield to make the "rotation" possible. I think, ideally, we'd have an infield with Camargo, Ozzie, and Dansby getting 500 plate appearances and whatever lefty addition we get to get ~450 plate appearances.

I think we could make an addition like that fairly cheaply on the market or for minimal prospect cost on the trade market. To me, it'd be a no brainer because it would add ~.100 OPS points to our offense against righties every game, while protecting against injury and whatnot.
 
Wonder if contreas would be a part. How valuable is he right now?

AA talked very highly of Contreras yesterday, if it's a 2 for 1, i doubt Contreras.

It's probably Riley and whatever pitcher Miami wants.
 
To put aside all those clamoring for a Donaldson signing------

"However it may seem from the outside, though, Braves GM Alex Anthopolous made clear today that he doesn’t see a need to seek change in the infield mix. As David O’Brien of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution tweets, the club’s top baseball decisionmaker says that, within the organization, “we feel like we’re set in the infield." "


That's from MLBTR article on Swanson having surgery on wrist

Unfortunately, that means nothing.

As far as baseball is concerned, GM-speak replaces English as the official language from November until February.
 
Sticking with Camargo/Riley at 3b until the deadline is probably the correct move.

You think so? You don't think something like a Jake Lamb trade or something along those lines might be beneficial to the infield's problem hitting RHP? I don't think the cost of acquisition for that type of move would be that bad.
 
Still an elite closer and still has elite velocity. I do understand the reasoning of not investing a lot of dollars into a reliever, but I also think that Kimbrel is exception to the rule just like Chapman or Rivera.

Rivera was an exception because he invented an elite pitch (cutter), and had 80 grade control.

Chapman (probably) is an exception because he throws harder than any pitcher in the history of the game. However, Chapman is the same age as Kimbrel, so it's a little premature to call Chapman an exception.

What unique quality does Kimbrel possess other than being a fan favorite?
 
Last edited:
You think so? You don't think something like a Jake Lamb trade or something along those lines might be beneficial to the infield's problem hitting RHP? I don't think the cost of acquisition for that type of move would be that bad.

Adding a platoon partner or utility guy is not the same as giving Donaldson $20M per year.

If Camargo is the guy at 3b I fully expect them to add a LHH to the IF bench mix.
 
Signing Brantley, trading for JT, and getting Donaldson in FA would be the ideal way in FA.

We're gonna have to trade some of these players eventually, cant prospect hoard forever.

If we had to trade, i'd go Wright/Riley for JT, Brantley on a 3 yr deal, and Donaldson on a 1/1. With whats left money wise, sign a high leverage bullpen arm. Probably no on Donaldson actually but we would need a bench bat. Marwin Gonzalez is ideal but i doubt he signs up to not be guaranteed to start.
 
Last edited:
I still hope that they make a move to acquire a lefty or switch hitter utility player who can provide an ~.800 OPS against RHP. Really, it doesn't even have to be a utility player. It could just be a 3rd baseman and then we could use Camargo to shift around the infield to make the "rotation" possible. I think, ideally, we'd have an infield with Camargo, Ozzie, and Dansby getting 500 plate appearances and whatever lefty addition we get to get ~450 plate appearances.

I think we could make an addition like that fairly cheaply on the market or for minimal prospect cost on the trade market. To me, it'd be a no brainer because it would add ~.100 OPS points to our offense against righties every game, while protecting against injury and whatnot.

This would be the perfect spot to add a couple less-attractive prospects to get Dietrich added to a Realmuto deal.

Then you have the flexibility to add Brantley/McCutchen, AND spend on the pen with plenty of money left for in-season additions - while also hanging onto the vast majority of our Pitching depth.

Not sure all these won't continue to change hourly for the next few weeks, but a Realmuto/Brantley/Britton/Dietrich offseason with plenty of money left would be an awfully nice Christmas present.
 
Last edited:
Hard pass on Kimbrel, given it would cost a pick and he'd probably want 4 guaranteed years or 3 years at a high cost, thats a hard pass for me.

Would suck to see him in Philly but Braves cant give that kinda coin to him. He's also been slowly declining the last couple years.
 
Last edited:
Adding a platoon partner or utility guy is not the same as giving Donaldson $20M per year.

If Camargo is the guy at 3b I fully expect them to add a LHH to the IF bench mix.

Oh, I thought you were saying that going with Riley/Camargo as the primary mix was the best move. But yeah I expect the same thing.
 
Signing Brantley, trading for JT, and getting Donaldson in FA would be the ideal way in FA.

We're gonna have to trade some of these players eventually, cant prospect hoard forever.

If we had to trade, i'd go Wright/Riley for JT, Brantley on a 3 yr deal, and Donaldson on a 1/1. With whats left money wise, sign a high leverage bullpen arm. Probably no on Donaldson actually but we would need a bench bat. Marwin Gonzalez is ideal but i doubt he signs up to not be guaranteed to start.

This is something I keep hearing, but Gonzalez could absolutely come close to 500 plate appearances as a super utility man if deployed correctly. He'd basically be a starter, but just at different positions depending on what matchups are on the table that day. We don't have a lineup full of guys without platoon problems.
 
This is something I keep hearing, but Gonzalez could absolutely come close to 500 plate appearances as a super utility man if deployed correctly. He'd basically be a starter, but just at different positions depending on what matchups are on the table that day. We don't have a lineup full of guys without platoon problems.

That's true but considering Bora$ is his agent, i doubt the Braves sign him for the money he ends up getting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top