GDT: Phillies vs Braves 9/3/14 12:10pm first pitch....
- Thread starter goldfly
- Start date
He is Chris Johnson with the bat and not the Chris Johnson who bats over .300. We already have a bunch of guys who don't walk and don't have much power, why do we need another one? I understand the need for defense but you're basically replacing Gattis with Chris Johnson's bat.
All you're doing is adding to the exact problem we've been trying to fix.
Still young enough to get better.
I'm a fan of Gattis but IMO Bethancourt is already better than Evan defensively with a considerably higher upside. it seems that NL pitching has adjusted to Gattis and gets him out on a regular bias since the ASB. I'd be curious whether Gattis' pre- and post- All Star Game batting average and slugging percentage statistics bear that out.
I can see him gaining some power but most guys don't just up and start taking walks after years of walking at a beyond abysmal rate.
NL pitching adjusted to Gattis last year. He hasn't been the same since he got hurt right before the ASB.
Bethancourt will never be as good offensively has Gattis has been this year.
While I agree it's doubtful that Bethancourt will ever approach Gattis' power numbers, there's no reason to believe that Christian can't at least match Evan's current batting average of .270.
Im a big fan of Bethancourt, but if you tell me Fredi did so knowing CB would get hits today, I will laugh in your face.
And some people need to consider sample size, CB was hitting .240 coming into the game.
I am a big fan of his and think hes a starting catcher that will develop to maybe league average numbers offensively for a catcher.....but this talk about him is comical.
And some people need to consider sample size, CB was hitting .240 coming into the game.
I am a big fan of his and think hes a starting catcher that will develop to maybe league average numbers offensively for a catcher.....but this talk about him is comical.
I have no doubt he can match .270. But hitting .270 with little power and no walks makes you Chris Johnson.
bravesnumberone
Well-known member
Well if he's not going to become anything, then he should replace Laird as backup catcher.
Bethancourt is a far better defensive catcher than anyone we currently have at that position who will only get better. I'd rather have his defense in the lineup but that's, obviously, an individual opinion and a tradeoff. Offensively, Bethancourt's numbers are still a fairly small sample size. He was sent back to the minors and appeared to adjust well at the plate. There's not much more he can prove at AAA so I think he deserves the opportunity to demonstrate whether or not he can improve at the MLB level.
bravesnumberone
Well-known member
Looked like Freeman was pissed off at the end of the game.
We got a win, but another blown opportunity losing two of three to these rejects.
We got a win, but another blown opportunity losing two of three to these rejects.
Once again, Fredi is a managerial genius. 7 runs with half of a bsquad lineup out there. 0 runs with A squad lineup.
50PoundHead
Hessmania Forever
Which is why you replace Chris Johnson.
I think everyone here except Niners and Dalyn would agree with this.
Actually, elite (or the potential to be) defensively plus suspect/unproven offensive skills makes you more like Andrelton Simmons than Chris Johnson IMO. Good MLB teams are built on pitching and defense--particularly defense up the middle. We have one great defender at those four key positions now and I'd like to add another.
When Molina came up with the Cardinals he was superior defensively but not much at the plate. He got the chance and made the most of it. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying Bethancourt is Molina but he has a similar foundation of defensive skills. He's the guy I'd build my team's future around at catcher.
Clearly, there are other opinions and factors that favor Gattis. I understand those. I'd still rather go forward with Bethancourt behind the plate for the reasons I've articulated in my last couple of posts.
nsacpi
Expects Yuge Games
The Gattis-Bethancourt situation is going to be very interesting to follow. I imagine we will get a good offer for one or both this off-season. Given the team's offensive struggles, I don't think we should be replacing Gattis' bat with a Chris Johnson equivalent. I appreciate there is a defensive upgrade with Bethancourt, but it is quite a stretch to say he is the catching equivalent of Simmons.
See if Boston would take Gattis for Betts. I'd love to have that kid in CF for us.
I don't know if it's any more of a stretch to say he'll never be better offensively than Johnson either. I do know that for the last couple of years Bethancourt has been rated one of the, if not the, best defensive catchers in the minor leagues. I'd like to give Bethancourt a lot more ABs before consigning him to the label of "another Chris Johnson."