Peraza In Play

I don't think Peraza is off the table. IF we could convert him to a prospect of more need, then we should. That being said, that never happens.
 
NinersSBChamps said:
And if he brings us a major league player, I consider it a win. I will take a proven player in the bigs over a prospect every time. Especially a prospect who people on this board think is gonna good.
Click to expand...
I have no problem with that. But if it brings us back a Chris Johnson-esque player, I'm going to be ***ing for sure! LOL.
 
NinersSBChamps said:
And if he brings us a major league player, I consider it a win. I will take a proven player in the bigs over a prospect every time. Especially a prospect who people on this board think is gonna good.
Click to expand...

You are underestimating the value of young cost controlled players (including highly rated prospects) and not taking into account that proven players are being paid market value for the most part. To build a winning team on a budget you need quite of bit of production at below market rates.
 
If we trade Peraza for a Chris Johnson-esque player, then I'll be going for what Niners seems to be drinking to ease the pain. :)

Seriously though, this all started over a nonsensical comment by Bowden so it is hard to take this discussion serious.
 
NinersSBChamps said:
Just so I am clear. Some people are gonna lose their **** if Peraza is traded. Guess these great prospects we have aren't really that great then if everyone's hero La Stella was decent for like a month and has since been traded.
Click to expand...

Hm no, no one said that. So we're not clear.
 
yeezus said:
Hm no, no one said that. So we're not clear.
Click to expand...

Maybe Niners should have phrased it this way...I have reason to believe some people are gonna...

He is a young padawan and we must be patient with him. He shows great promise.
 
I don't know why we'd trade Peraza. I agree his walk rate is low and his batting average is likely to dip some at the big league level. I don't know where that would put him in terms of OBP (probably around .320 or something). Supposedly good defensively. I don't think he's an automatic star, but he's a good piece to the puzzle.
 
Did Bowman put this Peraza thing out there before or after he listed a bunch of trades for us including a minor league second basemen in every trade?
 
How many prospects out there project better than Peraza? Including defense and the ability to play SS at a high level.
 
I think this was Bowden who put this out. Regardless, I don't see Peraza being included in any trade. I thought he would be more highly thought of by this board...I for one like him a lot. This season should be a better gauge of where he is.
 
We really have no clue as to how well he may do in the bigs. I think the reason he is highly regarded by everyone is that he is the lone position player we think could be ready within a year.
 
Tapate50 said:
How many prospects out there project better than Peraza? Including defense and the ability to play SS at a high level.
Click to expand...

If you go by BA's top 100 there are 18 2b/ss rated higher than Peraza, I don't believe they came out with the 2015 top 100 yet, so this is off the mid-season one from last year.
 
BRule said:
If you go by BA's top 100 there are 18 2b/ss rated higher than Peraza, I don't believe they came out with the 2015 top 100 yet, so this is off the mid-season one from last year.
Click to expand...

Peraza seems to be overrated on this board. Hes a solid project, but expecting him to do things right now is probably a pipedream unless he discovers his inner Rafael Furcal.
 
gilesfan said:
Peraza seems to be overrated on this board. Hes a solid project, but expecting him to do things right now is probably a pipedream unless he discovers his inner Rafael Furcal.
Click to expand...

Agreed, not really sure how or why the hype train got so out of control....probably because our system is so down. Can't believe people wouldn't trade Peraza....
 
Tapate50 said:
How many prospects out there project better than Peraza? Including defense and the ability to play SS at a high level.
Click to expand...

Maybe that's why the Braves would consider trading him. He's not going to play SS for us, but he could play SS for someone else, which would conceivably up his trade value.

I'll be honest that I didn't like his batting stance when I watched a short video of him. Can't see how he would ever generate any power. But his speed is supposedly a plus-plus tool.
 
BRule said:
Agreed, not really sure how or why the hype train got so out of control....probably because our system is so down. Can't believe people wouldn't trade Peraza....
Click to expand...

Who says they wouldn't trade him? And this board isn't the only Peraza-hype machine. Again, he's flawed but certainly not 'meh' as you and a few suggest.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top