Braves in talks w/ NL West club

thewupk said:
Just like Peraza was a year ago? If we move Simmons then that's yet another position that we have to hope gets filled by someone in the minors. If Simmons wasn't signed for those two extra years at such a team friendly deal then I would be more inclined to move him. But trading him now hurts the teams chances of trying to compete in 2017 if that is still the intended goal.
Click to expand...

Which is why I probably wouldn't move Simmons unless I get guy back that I'm convinced is a cornerstone piece that will be key to competing in 2017. I'm not dealing Simmons for a low-A talent. But Albies gives us a little room at SS. It's a gamble as Albies could always flame out or get hurt but sometimes you gotta take risks. If we can turn Simmons into a cornerstone piece and have Albies manning short in another year, we'll be better off than trading Simmons later for a lesser return.
 
Would the Dodgers even trade Seager? I know Seager is a beast but I don't wanna do a 1 for 1 for Simmons if we trade him. But at the same time we need an offensive bat in return for Simmons.
 
I can't say I'm in favor of trading Tron, but I reluctantly agree that making him available is the right move, given the circumstances. The level of interest that's already been reported probably underscores that.

If we trade him for anything less than a collection of MLB-ready (or near-ready) position-playing beasts, I will seriously have to reevaluate my March-September plans.
 
Hudson2 said:
Would the Dodgers even trade Seager? I know Seager is a beast but I don't wanna do a 1 for 1 for Simmons if we trade him. But at the same time we need an offensive bat in return for Simmons.
Click to expand...

Honestly, I highly doubt it. But, I agree. I only want to trade him if we can get "pieces" back. I like Seager, he's a boss, but I'd rather keep the proven guy instead of "hoping" it's 100% sure thing with Corey. It probably will be, but you never know.
 
UNCBlue012 said:
Honestly, I highly doubt it. But, I agree. I only want to trade him if we can get "pieces" back. I like Seager, he's a boss, but I'd rather keep the proven guy instead of "hoping" it's 100% sure thing with Corey. It probably will be, but you never know.
Click to expand...

There is absolutely no way Seager is part of any Simmons deal
 
Hudson2 said:
Would the Dodgers even trade Seager? I know Seager is a beast but I don't wanna do a 1 for 1 for Simmons if we trade him. But at the same time we need an offensive bat in return for Simmons.
Click to expand...

I'd do Simmons for Seager in a heartbeat. Seager is MLB ready and could be a perennial All Star at third. He's exactly the kind of piece we need. I'd probably add to the deal to get Seager.

That being said, I put the odds of the Dodgers trading him as slightly less than the odds of me landing a free agent deal with the Braves.
 
everyone is forgetting about our Gomes get from last year. yes that is right our 22 year phenom name Luis Valenzuela..

that is right. batted .429 for the Braves and .365 overall. has great range and only 8 errors last year. Albies who.. only a matter of time before he beats Simmons out for the starting job in ATL..
 
There's just so much in the workings. I'm so excited about our future, but trades (like this could be) will help us whether we are speeding it up or just stalling a couple more years. Our international signings are making me as excited as anything. Go forget about Maitan.
 
I heard a few people mention they would trade Freeman if Simmons is traded. At this point there aren't too many teams in need of a first baseman so I would hold on to him because you are NOT going to get good value for him.

As we stand, our most valuable pieces have to be Simmons, Miller, Teheran, Freeman....(on the big league roster, not including minors)
 
bravesfanMatt said:
everyone is forgetting about our Gomes get from last year. yes that is right our 22 year phenom name Luis Valenzuela..

that is right. batted .429 for the Braves and .365 overall. has great range and only 8 errors last year. Albies who.. only a matter of time before he beats Simmons out for the starting job in ATL..
Click to expand...

I think counting on Albies to beat out Simmons for the starting SS job anytime soon is reaching
 
@JeffPassan: When you're in Atlanta's position, you listen on everyone, even your most valuable assets. A full teardown can require a lot of creativity.
Click to expand...

I think they handled the teardown part just fine, the building back I'll believe it when I see it.
 
Granted, I don't know if a deal will even happen, let alone what we will get in return, but this even makes the Peraza deal look even worse in my opinion if this is what we are considering. It shows a lack of true understanding and forward thinking, as Peraza would have been a short term cost effective option at short that could have developed into something useful going forward and considering the fiasco that is Olivera at this point in time, I'm really scratching my head wondering what the hell is going on.

If Simmons is traded it better be for a massive massive haul. A franchise type everyday player preferably 3rd and or an corner outfielder that is ready or close to being ready, another position player of value, and some higher upside arms better be in the deal.
 
Tapate50 said:
Sure doesn't sound like the payroll squeeze will be lifted in the coming years. New stadium may just be to line the pockets of Lib.
Click to expand...

Like I've said many of times, I'll believe it when I see it. If the organization is serious about this mystical season going into 2017 and forward, now is the time that we should be making a run at some of the top tier younger free agents that are available. But all we've done is shed payroll and have yet to see much in the form of spending to find replacements at the MLB level.
 
For example: see the florida Marlins who completely re-launched their brand going into the new stadium. Went out and signed anyone and everyone. Had a terrible year 1 before the fire sale in the offseason...

I don't see us doing that...
 
bravesfanforlife88 said:
For example: see the florida Marlins who completely re-launched their brand going into the new stadium. Went out and signed anyone and everyone. Had a terrible year 1 before the fire sale in the offseason...

I don't see us doing that...
Click to expand...

And I don't want that, but I'd hope that we'd at least consider signing someone like Price to anchor the rotation or dare I say Heyward to build around going forward. Young talent that helps us in the short term and long-term while acquiring a need and using the depth that we've accumulated to fill other needs through trades and so forth.
 
Millwood1Hitter said:
And I don't want that, but I'd hope that we'd at least consider signing someone like Price to anchor the rotation or dare I say Heyward to build around going forward. Young talent that helps us in the short term and long-term while acquiring a need and using the depth that we've accumulated to fill other needs through trades and so forth.
Click to expand...

I wish we were in a place where we were close to being competitive, but as we stand, it seems like we are still in re-build mode and will be for a while. Also, why have I been hearing that there are budget constraints when we supposedly have $25-30 mil to spend this offseason...?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top