Keith Law's Top 100 Prospect Rankings

All those plus or plus plus command relievers out there. Soroka would totally fit in.

Joking aside, Soroka seems like the guy in our system that Law would be low on. High floor, control/commands well, good mental game.
 
for insiders the write up for the braves is up.

Riley has slider bat speed and not athletic....let the klaw hate come back.
 
Russ2dollas said:
for insiders the write up for the braves is up.

Riley has slider bat speed and not athletic....let the klaw hate come back.
Click to expand...

He's said that before, and I don't think it's a surprise to anybody. We just won't know what Riley's future is at least until he hits AA, and it may not be until he sees major league pitching that we really know if he can make up for his bat speed.
 
bravesfanMatt said:
Until Riley proves him wrong. Why hate.
Click to expand...

b/c it's a message board. And ppl like to hate Klaw.

I like him. He gives you an opinion and why he has that opinion.

You may not agree that Soroka's frame holds him back but at least you know where the guy's coming from with the rank or no rank.
 
Russ2dollas said:
b/c it's a message board. And ppl like to hate Klaw.

I like him. He gives you an opinion and why he has that opinion.

You may not agree that Soroka's frame holds him back but at least you know where the guy's coming from with the rank or no rank.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Personally, I don't get the knock on Soroka's frame. He looks like he could add weight, and his frame is very similar to Sale's. Of course, Law didn't like Sale, so...
 
Russ2dollas said:
for insiders the write up for the braves is up.

Riley has slider bat speed and not athletic....let the klaw hate come back.
Click to expand...

That's been Law's take for a while now. We'll see how that plays out. Troy Glaus might be a good comp for Riley and he never had what you'd call lightening bat speed.
 
smootness said:
Agreed. Personally, I don't get the knock on Soroka's frame. He looks like he could add weight, and his frame is very similar to Sale's. Of course, Law didn't like Sale, so...
Click to expand...

I don't get it either...just seems like I see a ton of SP body types. I don't see the strong texas SP as the only guy out there or even the majority. Lots of skinny guys. Lots of fat guys.

I think the DPeterson write up is interesting. I know "avg regular" doesn't excite anyone. But Avg left field bat is pretty decent. We have Kemp and Markakis around for too long and he's young. But a cheap, avg corner bat probably helps this team a lot.

Ruiz didn't make the rankings.

Much more realistic on Demerrite...80% he never plays in MLB. 20% chance he is a starting 2B.

The catcher we signed for 300k sounds really interesting. I didn't realize he was 25.....How much bat would he have to show to be on the roster next year? It's not like there is a lot holding him back.
 
Russ2dollas said:
I don't get it either...just seems like I see a ton of SP body types. I don't see the strong texas SP as the only guy out there or even the majority. Lots of skinny guys. Lots of fat guys.

I think the DPeterson write up is interesting. I know "avg regular" doesn't excite anyone. But Avg left field bat is pretty decent. We have Kemp and Markakis around for too long and he's young. But a cheap, avg corner bat probably helps this team a lot.

Ruiz didn't make the rankings.

Much more realistic on Demerrite...80% he never plays in MLB. 20% chance he is a starting 2B.

The catcher we signed for 300k sounds really interesting. I didn't realize he was 25.....How much bat would he have to show to be on the roster next year? It's not like there is a lot holding him back.
Click to expand...

This year for DPete is pretty big.
 
Russ2dollas said:
b/c it's a message board. And ppl like to hate Klaw.

I like him. He gives you an opinion and why he has that opinion.

You may not agree that Soroka's frame holds him back but at least you know where the guy's coming from with the rank or no rank.
Click to expand...

I wasn't being a d**k.. I like to hate Law too. but I don't because of his opinion on Riley. unfortunately he might be right. I have huge concerns about Riley, but I still hold him as a legit prospect until he struggles for a few years.

and Yes, Soroka has a great pitching frame.. There was a reddit photo of Meet and Greet Rome.. Dude is legit. http://imgur.com/DpYmESB
 
Law also adds that Sims has "no plane or life to his fastball" and "has" to move to the bullpen.

- Scouts wanted Minter in the ATL Top 10, Law doesn't like him as much because he's a "one inning reliever" with high injury risk b/c of his delivery.
- Wentz gets "Cole Hamels lite" comps
- Thinks Weigl could be up in September
 
Hawk said:
Law also adds that Sims has "no plane or life to his fastball" and "has" to move to the bullpen.

- Scouts wanted Minter in the Top 10, Law doesn't like him as much because he's a "one inning reliever" with high injury risk b/c of his delivery.
- Wentz gets "Cole Hamels lite" comps
- Thinks Weigl could be up in September
Click to expand...

I agree that Sims needs to go to the pen. I don't think he can cut it as a starter with the potential talent against him. He could be a high leverage reliever though. completely disagree on Minter, but oh well. Love the Wentz/Wegiel blurbs.

thanks Hawk.
 
Hawk said:
Law also adds that Sims has "no plane or life to his fastball" and "has" to move to the bullpen.

- Scouts wanted Minter in the ATL Top 10, Law doesn't like him as much because he's a "one inning reliever" with high injury risk b/c of his delivery.

- Wentz gets "Cole Hamels lite" comps

- Thinks Weigl could be up in September
Click to expand...

Does he mention if he thinks Weigel can stick in the rotation or as a BP guy?
 
Interesting that he sees Minter as a 1-inning guy (although just about all RPs are now, at least until you get to the playoffs) after his college career as a starter.

As for Demeritte, I'd say it's more like: 10% above-average starting 2B, 20% below-average starting 2B, 50% bench bat, 20% never plays in the majors. A guy with that kind of bat and glove seems like he'll probably have a place in the majors, it just may not be in the starting lineup and it may not be for very long.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top